400kVA vs 450kVA vs 500kVA Generator: Cat, Cummins or Cat?
400kVA vs 450kVA vs 500kVA generator: these are the three biggest generators we list, the Cat DE400E0, the Cummins C450D5 and the Cat DE500E0. At this level, buyers are usually comparing all three, and the decision is worth hundreds of thousands of rand. The most useful way to compare them isn’t the headline kVA, but how much continuous power each delivers, and what that costs per kilowatt.

400kVA vs 450kVA vs 500kVA generator: side by side
| Cat 400kVA | Cummins 450kVA | Cat 500kVA | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Model | DE400E0 | C450D5 | DE500E0 |
| Prime (continuous) | 350kVA / 280kW | About 409kVA / 327kW | 450kVA / 360kW |
| Standby | 400kVA / 320kW | 450kVA / 360kW | 500kVA / 400kW |
| Engine | Cat C13, 12.5 litre | Cummins QSZ13, 13 litre, XPI injection | Cat C15, 15.2 litre |
| Alternator | Cat | Stamford | Cat SR500 |
| Load acceptance | 100% in one step | Strong, electronic control | 100% in one step |
| Cooling | Rated to 55°C ambient | Designed for 50°C ambient | On the data sheet |
| Current per phase (standby) | About 577A | About 650A | About 722A |
| Typical transfer switch | 630A | 800A | 800A |
| Price | R590,000 excl. VAT / R678,500 incl. VAT | R655,500 excl. VAT / R753,825 incl. VAT | R725,000 excl. VAT / R833,750 incl. VAT |
| Price per prime kW | About R2,105 per kW | About R2,005 per kW | About R2,015 per kW |
All three are three phase and ordered in, with the lead time confirmed on your quote. Prices exclude installation, switchgear and fuel storage.
What the numbers tell you
Per kilowatt of continuous power, the Cummins 450kVA and the Cat 500kVA cost almost exactly the same, about R2,000 per kW. The Cat 400kVA costs a little more per kW, but it has the lowest total price. In plain terms:
- Going from the Cat 400kVA to the Cummins 450kVA costs about R65,500 more and adds about 47kW of continuous power.
- Going from the Cummins 450kVA to the Cat 500kVA costs about R69,500 more and adds about 33kW of continuous power.
The Cat 400kVA: the lowest outlay, built for heat

Choose the Cat DE400E0 if your continuous load is up to about 280kW and you want the lowest price. Its cooling is rated to 55°C, ideal for hot plant rooms, and it accepts its full load in one step. Our 400kVA price guide and 400kVA generator guide go into detail.
The Cummins 450kVA: the best value per kilowatt

Choose the Cummins C450D5 if your load is between about 280 and 330kW continuous. It’s the best value per kilowatt in this group, with a modern 13-litre engine using Cummins XPI electronic fuel injection, and a Stamford alternator. See our 450kVA generator guide.
The Cat 500kVA: the most power

Choose the Cat DE500E0 if you need up to 360kW continuously, or 400kW during outages. It has the biggest engine of the three, a 15.2-litre Cat C15, and takes its full load in one step, which matters for sites with large motors, lifts and chillers. See our 500kVA price guide and 500kVA generator guide.
Fuel use
For the same load, all three burn roughly a quarter of a litre of diesel per kWh produced, so fuel follows the load, not the badge. At full prime load, plan for roughly 70 litres an hour on the Cat 400kVA, 82 on the Cummins 450kVA and 90 on the Cat 500kVA. Exact figures come on each manufacturer’s data sheet with your quote. Check today’s diesel price, and plan bulk storage with our fuel management service.
Which one should you buy?
- Continuous load up to about 280kW: the Cat 400kVA.
- Continuous load about 280 to 330kW: the Cummins 450kVA.
- Continuous load about 330 to 360kW, or big motor starts: the Cat 500kVA.
- Critical site needing redundancy: consider two smaller sets in parallel, such as two 250kVA Pramacs.
Send us your electricity bills, or your maximum demand and largest motors, and we’ll recommend the right one, with installation planned by our own team. Request a quote, or browse our industrial generators.
New to prime and standby ratings? Read prime vs standby explained.
Frequently asked questions
Which is the best value: 400kVA, 450kVA or 500kVA?
Per kilowatt of continuous power, the Cummins 450kVA and Cat 500kVA are almost identical, at about R2,000 per kW. The Cat 400kVA has the lowest total price.
Which takes its full load in one step?
Both Cat generators, the 400kVA and 500kVA, accept 100% of their rated load in a single step.
What transfer switch does each need?
Typically 630A for the 400kVA, and 800A for the 450kVA and 500kVA, as your electrician specifies.
Are they all three phase?
Yes. All three are three-phase industrial generators.